Book Review: The Canary Murder Case by S. S. Van Dine (1927)

The Canary Murder Case by S. S. Van Dine is a classic mystery novel first published in 1927. It features Philo Vance, a wealthy and intellectual amateur detective who is often compared to Sherlock Holmes. The novel is set in New York City, and it revolves around the murder of a popular Broadway actress, Margaret Odell, who is nicknamed “The Canary” because of her beautiful singing voice.

The novel is well-written, and it keeps the reader engaged with its intricate plot and compelling characters. Van Dine’s writing style is elegant and sophisticated, and he uses complex language and literary allusions to create a sense of intellectualism that is often associated with his detective character, Philo Vance.

The story begins when Margaret Odell is found dead in her apartment, and the police are called in to investigate the case. Philo Vance, who is a friend of the victim’s wealthy and influential father, is also asked to help with the investigation. Vance immediately sets to work, examining the crime scene and interviewing the various suspects who had been present in the apartment at the time of the murder.

The suspects include the victim’s fiancé, Harry Gray, who is a struggling playwright; Dr. Ambrose Llewellyn, a psychiatrist who had been treating the victim for a nervous condition; Ada Mason, Margaret’s personal maid; and a number of other individuals who had some connection to the victim.

As the investigation progresses, Vance uncovers a number of clues that point to the identity of the murderer. He also demonstrates his impressive deductive skills and his vast knowledge of various subjects, including art, literature, and psychology.

One of the strengths of The Canary Murder Case is the way that Van Dine develops his characters. Each suspect has a distinct personality and motive, and the reader is left guessing as to who the real killer might be. In addition, the novel offers a fascinating glimpse into the world of New York City in the 1920s, with its glitzy Broadway shows, high-society parties, and eccentric personalities.

However, there are also some weaknesses in the novel. One of the main criticisms of The Canary Murder Case is that it is overly convoluted, with too many characters and plot twists that can be difficult to keep track of. In addition, some readers may find Philo Vance to be an insufferable know-it-all, with his constant pontificating and condescension towards the other characters.

Another issue with the novel is that it contains some racist and sexist language that is jarring to modern readers. For example, Vance frequently uses racial and ethnic slurs when referring to characters of different backgrounds, and the female characters in the novel are often portrayed as weak and emotional.

Despite these flaws, The Canary Murder Case remains an entertaining and engaging read for fans of classic mystery novels. It is a well-crafted whodunit that keeps the reader guessing until the very end, and it offers a fascinating snapshot of a bygone era in American history.

Overall, if you are a fan of classic mystery novels and are willing to overlook some of the outdated attitudes and language in the book, then The Canary Murder Case is definitely worth reading. Van Dine’s writing style is elegant and intelligent, and his protagonist, Philo Vance, is a fascinating and complex character who is sure to capture your interest.

You can pick up a copy of The Canary Murder Case here.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s