Movie Review: Anatomy of a Murder (1959)

In honor of James Stewart’s birthday today, let’s look at one of his last movies, the legal thriller, “Anatomy of a Murder.” “Anatomy of a Murder” is a 1959 American courtroom drama film directed by Otto Preminger. The film is based on a novel of the same name by Robert Traver (pen name of John D. Voelker) and is known for its realistic portrayal of the legal system and its complex exploration of moral ambiguity. It is based on the novel of the same name published in 1958. You can read my review of the novel here.

The story revolves around Paul Biegler (played by James Stewart), a small-town lawyer in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. Biegler is a former district attorney who is now struggling financially. He gets an opportunity to defend Lieutenant Frederick Manion (played by Ben Gazzara), a U.S. Army officer who is accused of murdering Barney Quill, a local bartender. The reason behind the murder is claimed to be Quill’s rape of Laura Manion (played by Lee Remick), Frederick’s wife.

Biegler takes on the case, believing that the defense of temporary insanity can prove Frederick’s innocence. As the trial begins, Biegler faces off against the tough and experienced prosecutor, Assistant Attorney General Claude Dancer (played by George C. Scott). The trial becomes a high-profile case, attracting media attention and public interest.

As the trial unfolds, Biegler discovers various layers of complexity in the case. He delves into the nature of Frederick and Laura’s relationship, as well as the events leading up to the murder. Biegler questions the witnesses, presents evidence, and challenges the credibility of the prosecution’s case. The trial becomes a battle of wits and legal maneuvering between Biegler and Dancer.

During the trial, Biegler calls in an expert witness, Dr. Matthew Smith (played by Brooks West), who testifies about the possibility of Frederick suffering from temporary insanity due to emotional disturbance caused by the alleged rape of his wife. Biegler also introduces evidence to suggest that Laura had a previous relationship with Quill, raising questions about her credibility and potential motives for the murder.

The courtroom drama intensifies, with Biegler’s defense strategy and Dancer’s prosecution tactics clashing. The film explores themes of justice, morality, and the flaws within the legal system. Ultimately, the jury must decide whether Frederick is guilty of murder or whether he acted under the influence of temporary insanity.

Without revealing the final verdict, “Anatomy of a Murder” offers a thought-provoking and morally complex exploration of the human condition and the pursuit of justice within the framework of the legal system. The film is celebrated for its intricate storytelling, strong performances, and its ability to challenge the audience’s perceptions of right and wrong.

“Anatomy of a Murder” (1959) features a stellar cast that delivers compelling performances.James Stewart portrays the lead character, Paul Biegler, a small-town lawyer. Stewart brings his trademark charm and charisma to the role, capturing the essence of a brilliant but unorthodox attorney. He effectively conveys Biegler’s determination, wit, and vulnerability, earning him an Academy Award nomination for Best Actor.

Lee Remick portrays Laura Manion, the wife of the accused Lieutenant Frederick Manion. Remick delivers a captivating performance, balancing Laura’s sensuality, vulnerability, and complexity. Her portrayal of a woman caught in a web of conflicting emotions adds depth to the character.

Ben Gazzara portrays the accused army officer, Frederick Manion. Gazzara skillfully captures Frederick’s brooding intensity and inner turmoil, presenting a complex and enigmatic character. He effectively conveys the internal struggles faced by Frederick, as well as his conflicting emotions and possible motivations for the crime.

George C. Scott plays the role of Claude Dancer, the ambitious and relentless prosecutor. Scott’s portrayal is dynamic and commanding, showcasing Dancer’s sharp intellect and formidable courtroom presence. His performance adds a layer of intensity and rivalry to the courtroom drama.

Arthur O’Connell plays the role of Parnell McCarthy, Biegler’s friend and colleague. O’Connell brings warmth and humor to the character, serving as a supportive figure for Biegler. His performance provides a lighthearted balance amidst the serious legal proceedings.

Eve Arden portrays Maida Rutledge, Biegler’s witty and sharp-tongued secretary. Arden injects humor and sass into the role, creating an engaging and memorable character. Her performance adds levity to the otherwise tense courtroom scenes.

The performances in “Anatomy of a Murder” contribute to the film’s overall success, with the actors delivering nuanced portrayals that bring the complex characters to life. The chemistry and talent of the cast elevate the story and contribute to the film’s enduring reputation.

“Anatomy of a Murder” explores several significant themes that are central to the film’s narrative and its examination of the legal system and human nature. The film delves into the complex relationship between justice and morality. It raises questions about the subjective nature of morality and how it intersects with the legal system. The characters grapple with their own sense of right and wrong, and the film challenges the audience to consider the gray areas in defining justice.

“Anatomy of a Murder” explores the elusive nature of truth and the subjective nature of perception. As the trial unfolds, multiple perspectives are presented, and it becomes apparent that the truth is often shaped by personal biases, flawed memories, and different interpretations of events. The film prompts viewers to question their own assumptions and the reliability of their perceptions.

The movie examines the strategies employed by lawyers to manipulate and shape the outcome of a trial. It highlights the tactical nature of legal proceedings, as attorneys utilize various techniques to present their case, challenge witnesses, and influence the jury. The film sheds light on the ethical dilemmas faced by lawyers and the potential for the legal system to be swayed by theatricality and manipulation.

“Anatomy of a Murder” explores themes of gender dynamics and sexuality. The film addresses the controversial subject of rape and its impact on the characters involved. It delves into society’s attitudes towards female sexuality, the dynamics of power within relationships, and the notion of consent. The portrayal of Laura Manion as a complex, multi-dimensional character challenges traditional stereotypes and perceptions.

The film delves into the depths of human nature, highlighting its complexities, contradictions, and flaws. The characters in the movie are flawed and morally ambiguous, grappling with their own desires, motivations, and weaknesses. “Anatomy of a Murder” offers a nuanced exploration of human behavior and raises questions about the extent to which individuals are responsible for their actions.

The film explores the concept of moral responsibility in the context of a criminal trial. It raises questions about accountability, the boundaries of self-defense, and the influence of external circumstances on individual choices. “Anatomy of a Murder” challenges viewers to consider the moral implications of their actions and the consequences of personal decisions. These themes contribute to the thought-provoking nature of the film, elevating it beyond a typical courtroom drama and inviting audiences to reflect on broader societal and philosophical questions.

Anatomy of a Murder” (1959) is generally regarded as a highly acclaimed film; however, like any work, it is not without its flaws. With the film’s runtime of over two hours can feel slow at times, with extended courtroom sequences and detailed examinations of the legal process you better be ready to sit and watch the movie. It can be a slog, if your in the mood for a snappy noir. The deliberate pacing may not appeal to viewers seeking a faster-paced narrative.

The film is known for its extensive dialogue, with lengthy conversations and exchanges between characters. While this is a characteristic of the film’s realism and attention to detail, it’s again not a film for all occasions. Even I, who like movies with discursive dialogue sometimes want to fast-forward through long, meandering monologues.

“Anatomy of a Murder” has a real problem with it’s portrayal of rape and how it handles the female victim. It’s obviously a product of the time, but as a woman it’s hard to stomach. Unfortunately, I know that women are often treated terribly when they report a rape or sexual violence. If you have been a victim of such violence- you may find it difficult to watch this movie so proceed with caution. Unfortunately, these attitudes are reflected in original novel as well.

The film was praised for its intelligent script, strong performances, and its realistic portrayal of the legal system. Critics commended the film’s exploration of complex moral and ethical questions, its nuanced characters, and the thought-provoking nature of its themes.

“Anatomy of a Murder” received seven Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture, Best Director (Otto Preminger), and Best Actor (James Stewart). The film received critical recognition for its screenplay, performances, and overall craftsmanship.

The film’s examination of controversial subject matter and its frank portrayal of sexual themes were considered groundbreaking for its time. It sparked discussions and debates about censorship, freedom of expression, and the boundaries of representation in cinema.

Overall, while “Anatomy of a Murder” may have some minor flaws or criticisms, it remains widely celebrated as a significant and influential film in the courtroom drama genre. Its thought-provoking exploration of moral ambiguity, its strong performances, and its realistic portrayal of the legal system continue to resonate with audiences and critics alike.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

        Leave a Reply

        Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

        You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

        Facebook photo

        You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

        Connecting to %s