Golden Age of Detective Fiction

“The Adventure of the Italian Nobleman” is a short story by Agatha Christie featuring the famous Belgian detective Hercule Poirot. The story was first published in the UK in 1935 as part of The Strand Magazine. This publication brought another intriguing case to Christie’s readers, involving Poirot’s sharp investigative skills.

In 1937, the story was included in the collection Murder in the Mews, published in the UK. This collection gathered several of Christie’s shorter works featuring Poirot. In the same year, the story made its way to the US audience as part of the collection Dead Man’s Mirror. These collections helped cement the story’s place within the larger Poirot canon and showcased Christie’s talent for crafting engaging mysteries in a compact format.

Over the years, “The Adventure of the Italian Nobleman” has been included in various reprints and anthologies, allowing new generations of readers to enjoy one of Hercule Poirot’s classic cases.

Plot Synopsis:

In the cozy confines of their shared rooms, Hercule Poirot and Captain Hastings were enjoying a quiet evening with their neighbor, Dr. Hawker. The tranquility of the moment was shattered when Dr. Hawker’s housekeeper burst in with alarming news: Count Foscatini had urgently phoned the doctor, crying out for help.

Poirot, Hastings, and Dr. Hawker rushed to the Count’s flat in Regent’s Court without wasting a moment. Upon arrival, they found the lift attendant unaware of any trouble. The attendant mentioned that Graves, the Count’s manservant, had left half an hour earlier without indicating anything was amiss. The flat was locked, but the building manager soon opened it for them. Inside, they were met with a grim scene: a table set for three, meals finished, and Count Foscatini dead, his head brutally crushed by a small marble statue.

Poirot’s keen eyes immediately turned to the remains on the table. He took a particular interest in the food, noting that while the main course was entirely consumed, little of the side dish and none of the desserts were eaten. His sharp observation skills were at play as he noted that the dying man had replaced the phone receiver after his desperate cry for help.

As the police arrived, so did Graves. He recounted that two guests had visited Foscatini the previous day: a man in his forties, Signor Ascanio, and a younger man. According to Graves, he overheard threats during their conversation, after which the Count invited the men to dinner the following evening. Graves claimed that on the night of the murder, Foscatini unexpectedly gave him the night off after dinner when the port was served.

Signor Ascanio was swiftly arrested, but Poirot’s sharp mind identified three points of interest: the black coffee, the relatively untouched side dish and dessert, and the undrawn curtains. Ascanio had an alibi from the Italian ambassador, raising suspicions of a diplomatic cover-up. When confronted by Poirot, Ascanio admitted that Foscatini was a blackmailer. His morning appointment had been to pay the demanded money, arranged through the embassy where he worked.

The Review

Christie’s iconic detective is at his best in this story. Poirot’s keen observational skills and psychological insight drive the narrative forward. His methodical approach and logical deductions are a joy to follow, reminding readers why he is one of the most beloved detectives in literary history.

As the narrator, Hastings provides a grounded and accessible viewpoint. His amiable nature and occasional naivety perfectly counter Poirot’s brilliance, adding a layer of charm to the story.

Though his presence is felt mainly through the investigation, the count’s enigmatic character adds depth to the plot. His mysterious past and social interactions are pivotal in unraveling the case.

Christie’s writing in “The Adventure of the Italian Nobleman” is concise and engaging. Her knack for creating vivid characters and maintaining suspense within a short story format is evident. The dialogue is sharp, and the pacing ensures readers remain invested in the unfolding mystery.

“The Adventure of the Italian Nobleman” is a stellar example of Agatha Christie’s mastery in crafting a compelling whodunit. The story’s intricate plot and Poirot’s analytical brilliance make it an enjoyable read for mystery enthusiasts. While it may not be as complex as some of her full-length novels, it showcases Christie’s ability to deliver a satisfying and clever mystery in a shorter format.

This story earns four stars for its engaging plot, well-drawn characters, and the quintessential charm of Hercule Poirot. It’s a must-read for fans of classic detective fiction and anyone who appreciates a well-told mystery.

Dive into this delightful tale and join Poirot as he unravels the mystery behind the death of the Italian nobleman. You won’t be disappointed!

Midsummer Mysteries Reviews

Story #1: The Blood-Stained Pavement

Story #2: The Double Clue

Story #3: Death on the Nile

Story # 4: Harlequin’s Lane