The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle: Holmes for the Holidays
Few Sherlock Holmes stories capture the warm glow of the holidays quite like The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle. Blending festive London streets, comic misadventures, and a glittering stolen gem, this classic tale showcases not only Holmes’ sharp deductive brilliance but also Arthur Conan Doyle’s quieter themes of mercy and human fallibility. It remains one of the most beloved entries in the canon—and for good reason
Publication History
The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle first appeared in The Strand Magazine in January 1892, illustrated by the incomparable Sidney Paget. It was later collected in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (1892). As one of the earliest Holmes stories, it helped solidify Holmes and Watson as fixtures of Victorian detective fiction. It demonstrated that mystery could flourish in the season of warmth, laughter, and goodwill.
Because it is set at Christmastime, it is one of the few Holmes adventures with a distinctly festive atmosphere—twinkling shop windows, bustling streets, and the contrast between holiday cheer and criminal intrigue.
Synopsis
The story opens with a decidedly odd puzzle: a battered Christmas goose and a gentleman’s hat left behind after a scuffle on a London street. Watson visits Holmes on the second morning after Christmas and finds him examining the abandoned hat with characteristic relish.
But upon carving the goose, its true secret emerges: not crumbs and stuffing, but the Blue Carbuncle, a valuable jewel recently stolen from the Countess of Morcar. The discovery instantly electrifies Holmes:
“It is one of the most precious stones in the world.”
Tracing the chain of custody of the goose—starting with the unfortunate Henry Baker, the hat’s owner—Holmes and Watson realize, this man has no idea about the goose’s special catgo
They must then embark on an investigation that takes them from back-alley poultry markets to Covent Garden. Their pursuit eventually leads them to the real culprit, who fed the Blue Carbuncle to the goose that would be his Christmas dinner, but it got loose in the yard pen, and he took home a different goose with the same tail markings.
As the killer recounts his futile and humorous debacle of trying to find the right Christmas goose, his guilt quickly collapses under Holmes’ calm scrutiny.
Just when the story seems poised for the usual criminal apprehension, Holmes does something surprisingly humane: he sets the sneak thief free, convinced that terror has reformed him more effectively than prison could.
“I suppose that I am commuting a felony, but i t is just possible that I am saving a soul.”
Review
The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle is one of Conan Doyle’s most delightful tales—not because it involves a grand scheme or a dangerous villain, but because it leans into humor, humanity, and holiday warmth.
The opening premise alone—a mystery centered around a goose and an old hat—has an almost comedic charm. Holmes’ dry analysis of the hat is amusing:
“He picked it up and gazed at it in the peculiar introspective fashion which was characteristic of him. “It is perhaps less suggestive than it might have been,” he remarked, “and yet there are a few inferences which are very distinct, and a few others which represent at least a strong balance of probability. That the man was highly intellectual is of course obvious upon the face of it, and also that he was fairly well-to-do within the last three years, although he has now fallen upon evil days. He had foresight, but has less now than formerly, pointing to a moral retrogression, which, when taken with the decline of his fortunes, seems to indicate some evil influence, probably drink, at work upon him. This may account also for the obvious fact that his wife has ceased to love him.”
“My dear Holmes!”
“He has, however, retained some degree of self-respect,” he continued, disregarding my remonstrance. “He is a man who leads a sedentary life, goes out little, is out of training entirely, is middle-aged, has grizzled hair which he has had cut within the last few days, and which he anoints with lime-cream. These are the more patent facts which are to be deduced from his hat. Also, by the way, that it is extremely improbable that he has gas laid on in his house.”
Holmes deduces the owner’s entire lifestyle from a shabby felt hat, and Watson’s good-natured bewilderment provides a delightful contrast. The case unfolds with an almost Dickensian flavor, full of bustling city streets, kindly pub-goers, and the occasional irritable salesman.
Although the crime itself is small-scale compared to other Holmes stories, the story is a showcase of the detective’s method: tracing clues backward, understanding human nature, and using logic to uncover character.
The step-by-step reasoning—from hat-reading to turkey-tracing—makes this an ideal introduction to Sherlock Holmes for new readers and a satisfying display for longtime fans.
What sets this tale apart, though, is its more humorous and lighthearted tone. A Christmas goose is filled with more than just stuffing- but a precious jewel. Holmes is at his most genial, and his deductions border on playful facetiousness- making grandiose pronouncements to Watson about the hat-owner’s fortunes, marital status, and general happiness all on the state of his hat. Watson, dryly sardonic, has this sarcastic and iconic line in retort to Holmes’ smug pronouncements:
I have no doubt that I am very stupid, but I must confess that I am unable to follow you….
Instead, the oft-dog-hanged, bewildered man of TV and film spends his Christmas helping Holmes and needling him about his more fantastical pronouncements as they race about snow-dripped London.
There’s much jollification in this holiday tale, but a few questions still remain in my mind- while mercifully letting the real jewel thief go, Holmes does let an innocent man sit in prison for stealing the stone. The in-story explanation, “the case is flimsy and will be dismissed,” handwaves away what is decidedly not a lovely Christmas for the imprisoned man. However, Holmes’ compassion was stretched to one person besides Watson, so he should be congratulated on that point!
Another unclear point in the story is whether Holmes collects the reward money for catching the thief instead of a more desperate Henry Baker, for whom the 1000-pound reward would be life-changing. Since it’s not explicitly stated either way, I like to imagine Henry Baker gets a change in his financial fortunes at Christmas, as well as a new, deliciously cooked goose from Sherlock Holmes.
The Verdict
The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle remains a seasonal favorite because it combines everything readers love about Sherlock Holmes—sharp deduction, witty dialogue, and atmospheric London settings—with a heartfelt Christmas message. Its gentle humor and satisfying mystery make it perfect for reading by the glow of holiday lights or sharing aloud with fellow mystery lovers.
It may be one of Holmes’ lighter adventures, but it is also one of his most human—and for that, it shines as brilliantly as the gemstone at its center.
#Christmas2025ReadingChallenge | #20BooksofChristmas
This is my second review for the #Christmas2025Reading Challenge and #20BooksOfChristmas. You can check out what else I’m planning to review this holiday season here.
2025: 20 Books of Christmas Reviews
- A Christmas Tragedy by Agatha Christie (1930) | REVIEW
- I Am Half-Sick of Shadows by Alan Bradley (2011) | REVIEW
2024: 20 Books of Christmas Reviews
- The Night of Fearby Moray Dalton (1931) | REVIEW
- Mystery in White by J. Jefferson Farjeon (1937) | REVIEW
- Murder After Christmas by Rupert Latimer (1944) | REVIEW
- Murder for Christmas by Francis Duncan (1949) | REVIEW
- Groaning Spinney a. k. a. Murder in the Snow by Gladys Mitchell (1950) | REVIEW
- The Adventure of the Christmas Pudding by Agatha Christie (1960) | REVIEW
- The Twelve Deaths of Christmas by Marian Babson (1979) | REVIEW
- Murder on a Mystery Tour by Marian Babson (1985) REVIEW
- Mistletoe Murder by Leslie Meier (1993) | REVIEW
- Death at Wentwater Court by Carola Dunn (1994) | REVIEW
- A Highland Christmas by M. C. Beaton (1999) | REVIEW
- The Christmas Murder Game by Alexandra Benedict (2021) | REVIEW
- The Christmas Appeal by Janice Hallett (2023) | REVIEW
- Hercule Poirot’s Silent Night by Sophie Hannah (2023) REVIEW
- Everyone This Christmas Has A Secret by Benjamin Stevenson (2024) | REVIEW
Golden Age of Detective Fiction 
Leave a comment